We sort your Self Assessment for you. £149, all in.

Fast, effortless and 100% online.  Learn more

We sort your Self Assessment for you. £149, all in.

Bilbo, Frodo, and their tax accountant

  • 5 min read
  • 30 Aug 2022
Lord of the rings - and the tax return

What if instead of throwing the one ring into the fires of Mount Doom, Frodo decided to cash in and treat it as a gift from his uncle. The only thing is, being the most powerful of all rings and all, and being forged by the Dark Lord Sauron himself, it had a hefty price tag. Especially if he cashed it in by selling it back to Sauron. Then it was worth, what, the value of ruling supreme over Middle Earth? Incalculable.

Unfortunately, Bilbo passes away soon after Frodo takes off with the ring. Without its powers to help him live his best life, his time comes earlier than expected. 

Even more unfortunately for Frodo, Bilbo leaves him his house in The Shire. Combined with the value of the ring, he now owes Inheritance Tax. And a lot of it. He has 6 months to cough up 40% of Bilbo’s estate that’s worth way more than £325,000 – the maximum you can accept as a gift tax-free within a given tax year

The HMRC was coming. 

What next?

Surely it’s fine. Someone that considered a perilous journey all the way to Mordor could manage a tiny task like a tax return, right? 

“It is a strange fate that we should suffer so much fear and doubt over so small a thing,” Boromir said. 

Exactly, Frodo thinks, although he’s not certain where he came from. Frodo heads straight for the government gateway to start the process of his Self Assessment.

When he gets to the Overview page, he’s surprised by the volume of hyperlinks that seem to divert him from where he needs to be. Curious, he thinks. He navigates down to Deadlines under which are three options:

  1. Self employed or a sole trader
  2. Not self-employed
  3. Registering a partner or partnership

Hmm, he thinks and clicks, Not self-employed, although he isn’t sure that any accurately describes his status as a hobbit. He is the chosen one, after all.

He clicks Register Now, but when the page loads, he’s confronted by a selection of forms. 

“What’s this?” he says aloud. 

Boromir laughs from behind him. “Frodo, one does not simply walk into the government gateway.” 

“Urgh, be quiet, Boromir,” he says, and closes the tab. 

It’s at this point that Frodo realises that he hasn’t even checked whether what he needs to do is a Self Assessment. He returns to Google. “My old friend,” he thinks to himself, the words of his uncle haunting him.  

He types in, Inheritance Tax (IHT) and is directed back to gov.uk. He sighs, frustrated by the time wastage, but clicks on it anyway.

Inheritance Tax

On the IHT page, it looks like he’s in the right place to pay. Joy of joys – except he needs a payment reference number. And he can only make the payment after he’s had the reference number for 3 weeks; or he has to wait 3 weeks for the reference number to arrive. It’s hard to tell. He scratches his hairy foot – and why would you get a payment reference number before making a payment? 

“It’s the job that’s never started as takes longest to finish,” Sam says, appearing over Frodo’s shoulder.

Frodo jumps. 

“Leave it, Sam,” he snaps. 

But he agrees. He starts to wish that he’d just chucked the ring into the fires of Mount Doom after all. 

Three weeks later

The payment reference number arrives by post, but Frodo can’t even pretend to be relieved. He’s had time to think about things and a few concerns have come to his attention:

  • His uncle, Bilbo, stole the ring from Gollum – so perhaps it’s not worth the value of reigning supreme over Middle Earth after all, but whatever it was worth to Gollum. And what’s that, just a few freshly-caught fish from the river? 
  • If he sells it to Sauron, the profit will be massive – a few freshly-caught fish vs. the value of ruling Middle Earth supreme. 
  • Frodo also owes tax on the profit a.k.a. Capital Gains Tax (CGT).

All’s well that ends better

Cross and dejected, Frodo accepts that he needs help. He journeys to a land far, far away (ok, it’s Rivendell) and consults with the elves who tell him of a mystical force called TaxScouts. As it happens, they’re 100% online so he could have saved himself the journey, but he tries not to focus on the negatives. 

For just £149, they link him with a friendly, expert accountant who explains all he needs to know about the Inheritance Tax and Capital Gains Tax implications of his sale of the one ring. Unfortunately, TaxScouts don’t deal with Inheritance Tax themselves, but they point him in the direction of the Inheritance Tax Probate Helpline

When it comes to the Capital Gains Tax, TaxScouts help him complete his tax return in just a few days, asking for no more than some documents and information about Bilbo’s estate/the sale to Sauron in return. 

“I would rather spend one lifetime with you, than face all the ages of this world alone,” Frodo says to his accountant once the return is filed and completed.

He quickly regrets this declaration. Maybe it was too much. He’s just so grateful!

“No worries,” the accountant says. 

Frodo wonders whether it was a mistake to sell the ring back to Sauron, condemning Middle Earth to a tyranny of fear and conflict for the sake of his own riches… 

…but that’s a story for another day.

TaxScouts Newsletter

Want regular tips from us?

Sign up for important updates, deadline reminders and basic tax hacks sent straight to your inbox.

"*" indicates required fields

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.